Freedom and Fresh Starts

The Key Mara Chose · Chapter 1 of 6

Chapter 1

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

The first time Elias Mercer asked Mara to enter his cabin, he expected her to judge him.

Instead, she opened the shutters.

Sunlight poured through windows that had not been properly uncovered in weeks, cutting bright golden paths through suspended dust. It revealed dirty plates stacked beside a cold stove, shirts hanging from chair backs, empty coffee tins scattered near the hearth, dried mud ground into the floorboards, and a collection of weapons that seemed better cared for than anything else in the room.

Mara stood silently in the middle of it all.

Elias waited near the door.

At thirty-seven, Elias Mercer had faced men who swore they would kill him before allowing themselves to be taken alive. He had tracked fugitives through snow, desert, rain, and mountain country. He had slept under wagons, beneath rocky ledges, and once inside the hollow trunk of a dead cottonwood tree while three armed thieves searched for him less than fifty yards away.

People in the territory called him fearless.

At that moment, he felt strangely uncomfortable beneath the quiet gaze of one widow holding a broom.

“Well?” Elias asked.

Mara looked at the room.

Then at him.

“You live like this?”

Elias glanced around as though seeing the cabin for the first time.

“I've been busy.”

“That is not an answer.”

“It was the one I had.”

For a second, something almost resembling amusement touched Mara's face.

Almost.

Then she walked to another shutter and pushed it open.

More sunlight entered.

Elias squinted.

“You trying to blind me?”

“I am trying to discover whether your floor still exists.”

“It exists.”

“Then today we will prove it.”

That was how Mara began working in Elias Mercer's cabin.

She lived less than a mile away in a smaller house near a dry creek bed. Her husband had died of fever eight years earlier, and much of her family had moved south after the railroad pushed closer to the settlement. Mara had remained.

Some people in town did not understand why.

Others had plenty of opinions.

Elias had learned years earlier that frontier towns always had opinions about people who lived differently, spoke differently, worshiped differently, or simply refused to explain themselves.

Mara received more of those opinions than most.

She was Apache.

That fact alone was enough for certain shopkeepers to watch her hands whenever she entered their stores. Enough for women to lower their voices when she passed. Enough for men who had never spoken a full sentence to her to decide what kind of woman she must be.

Elias hated that kind of cowardice.

He had seen brave men die.

He had also seen frightened men become cruel whenever they discovered someone society allowed them to mistreat.

Mara carried herself as though she had long ago decided she would survive both.

The first time Elias had approached her house, she had been chopping wood.

She saw him coming.

She did not stop.

Elias dismounted, tied his horse to a post, and waited until she finished splitting the log.

“You need something?” she asked.

“I do.”

“If you came about the horse tracks behind my house, they belong to Daniel Crowley's cattle hands. They cut across my land twice this week.”

“I didn't.”

“Then why are you here?”

Elias removed his hat.

That seemed to surprise her.

“I need someone to help with my cabin.”

Mara stared.

“Help how?”

“Cleaning. Cooking when I'm gone. Keeping things from…” He searched for the right word. “Falling apart.”

“You mean your house.”

“Cabin.”

“House.”

“Cabin.”

“If you sleep there, eat there, and expect the roof to remain over your head, it is a house.”

Elias had nearly smiled.

“Fine. House.”

Mara rested both hands on the ax handle.

“Why me?”

It was a fair question.

Elias answered it honestly.

“Because people say you work hard.”

“People say many things about me.”

“I don't listen to most of them.”

“And the rest?”

“I decide for myself.”

That answer changed something in her expression.

Not trust.

Not yet.

But interest.

Elias offered wages that were better than what the hotel paid its kitchen workers and promised she would never be expected to remain after dark unless she chose to.

Mara studied him for several uncomfortable seconds.

Then she nodded.

“I'll come tomorrow.”

Now tomorrow had arrived.

And by noon, Elias regretted ever inviting sunlight into his home.

Mara had discovered things.

Terrible things.

A skillet with something burned inside it so long ago Elias could no longer identify the original meal.

Two socks hidden beneath the bed.

A broken whiskey bottle under a cupboard.

A dead mouse behind a flour sack.

Mara held up the mouse by its tail.

Elias stared.

“That isn't mine.”

“No?”

“No.”

“Then perhaps it was paying rent.”

She threw it outside.

By afternoon, the cabin had begun transforming.

The floor appeared.

The table became visible.

The windows opened.

Clean water steamed on the stove.

Mara worked without wasting movement. She did not complain. She did not chatter to fill silence. She simply moved through the space with confidence, deciding where things belonged as though the house itself had been waiting years for someone to tell it what it was supposed to be.

Elias repaired a fence outside, though he checked the window more often than necessary.

He told himself he was making sure she had everything she needed.

That was not entirely true.

He watched because seeing another person moving inside his house felt strange.

For years, Elias had come home to darkness.

He would light a lamp, heat beans, clean his revolver, and sleep.

Sometimes he remained away for weeks because returning had no particular purpose.

A man could sleep anywhere.

Home required someone to notice whether he came back.

By evening, the smell of cornbread drifted through the open window.

Elias froze beside the fence.

It was such a simple smell.

Cornmeal.

Hot iron.

A little butter.

But memory rose with it.

His mother standing in a kitchen when he was nine.

His younger sister laughing.

His father washing his hands before supper.

All gone now.

Disease.

War.

Distance.

Life had scattered the Mercer family until Elias became the last piece with nowhere left to fit.

He entered the cabin slowly.

Mara was placing a pot of beans on the table.

“You don't have enough salt,” she said.

Elias looked around.

The room seemed larger.

There were no dirty dishes.

His shirts had been folded.

The stove had been scrubbed.

Someone had placed the chair properly beneath the table instead of leaving it crooked.

“You moved my ammunition.”

“It was beside the flour.”

“I knew where it was.”

“The flour did not appreciate the company.”

He looked toward the shelf.

His cartridges sat neatly in a wooden box.

Elias shook his head.

“You reorganized my entire life.”

“No. Only the dangerous parts.”

She picked up her shawl.

Elias looked at the food.

“You made supper.”

“You paid for cooking.”

“Still.”

Mara paused.

“Still what?”

“Thank you.”

She looked at him then.

Directly.

Perhaps she had expected many things from Elias Mercer.

Orders.

Distance.

Suspicion.

Maybe even disrespect.

Gratitude seemed to surprise her.

“You're welcome,” she said.

She left before sunset.

Elias stood alone in the cabin afterward.

Except the place no longer felt entirely empty.

That troubled him more than it should have.

For the next three weeks, Mara came whenever Elias was in town and prepared food for several days whenever he rode away.

Their conversations remained brief at first.

“Coffee?”

“Yes.”

“You need more firewood.”

“I'll cut it.”

“You said that yesterday.”

“I was busy yesterday.”

“You were sitting on the porch.”

“I was thinking.”

“Thinking does not split firewood.”

Somehow, that became normal.

Elias returned from a three-day hunt and found a small jar of dried herbs beside his stove.

“What is this?”

“For your cough.”

“I don't have a cough.”

“You coughed six times before leaving.”

“You counted?”

“I was trying to decide whether you would survive long enough to pay me.”

He stared at her.

Mara's mouth moved.

Not quite a smile.

But closer.

One evening he found her repairing a torn curtain.

“I can buy another one.”

“You could.”

“Then why sew it?”

“Because something torn is not always something useless.”

The words stayed with him.

Elias watched her fingers draw the thread through cloth.

Something torn is not always something useless.

He wondered if she meant the curtain.

He wondered if she knew he was wondering.

The town noticed Mara visiting his cabin.

Of course it did.

Frontier towns noticed everything.

At Caldwell's General Store, two cattlemen stopped talking when Elias entered.

One smirked.

“Mercer.”

Elias selected coffee from the shelf.

The other man said, “Hear you've hired yourself some domestic help.”

Elias kept shopping.

“That's what hiring means.”

The men laughed.

“You know what people are saying.”

Elias turned.

The laughter stopped.

“What are people saying?”

Neither man answered.

Elias stepped closer.

He did not raise his voice.

He never needed to.

“If you're brave enough to repeat something about Mara when she's not here, you should be brave enough to say it when I ask.”

The first man looked away.

“Didn't mean anything.”

“Good.”

Elias placed his coffee on the counter.

“Keep it that way.”

Word traveled.

After that, people became careful around him.

Mara apparently heard what happened.

She confronted him the next afternoon.

“You threatened two men at Caldwell's.”

“I didn't threaten anyone.”

“They say otherwise.”

“Men hear threats whenever somebody expects them to behave.”

“I do not need you fighting my battles.”

Elias leaned against the porch railing.

“I know.”

“Then why did you?”

“Because they weren't only your battles.”

Mara studied him.

He continued.

“If men think they can insult someone under my roof, they are insulting me too.”

Something shifted behind her eyes.

“You say that easily.”

“No.”

Elias looked toward the distant hills.

“I don't.”

Mara seemed to understand there was more behind those words.

But she did not ask.

That was one thing Elias valued about her.

She waited for truths instead of dragging them from people.

Two days later, Elias rode home just before dark.

Mara was standing beside the porch.

The instant she saw him, her expression changed.

Blood had dried across Elias's knuckles.

A bruise darkened beneath his left eye.

His lower lip was split.

Mara folded her arms.

“What happened?”

“Horse slipped.”

“Your horse punched you?”

Elias sighed.

“There was disagreement.”

“With whom?”

“A man who didn't want to come quietly.”

“And did he?”

“Eventually.”

Mara pointed inside.

“Sit.”

“I've had worse.”

“I didn't ask.”

Elias stopped.

No sheriff ordered him around like that.

No deputy.

No judge.

Certainly no outlaw.

Yet something about the firmness in Mara's voice made the hardened bounty hunter walk inside and sit beside the table.

She heated water.

Elias removed his coat.

His shoulder hurt more than he wanted to admit.

Mara placed a basin near him and took his hand.

The contact made both of them pause.

Her fingers were warm.

His knuckles were swollen.

“This may hurt,” she said.

“I'll survive.”

“You say that about everything.”

“Usually true.”

Mara cleaned the blood away carefully.

Elias watched her face.

She was concentrating on his hand, dark hair falling loosely near her cheek.

There was nothing romantic about warm water and bruised knuckles.

Nothing a sensible man should fear.

Yet Elias felt his chest tighten.

He had stitched his own wounds beside campfires.

He had pulled bullets from men who later tried to kill him.

He had once ridden thirty miles with a broken rib because there was nobody to call for help.

Needing people was dangerous.

Depending on them was worse.

But when Mara wrapped a clean strip of cloth around his injured hand, something inside Elias hurt more sharply than the injury.

Because he suddenly remembered what care felt like.

And realized how long he had lived without it.

Mara tied the cloth.

“Done.”

Elias looked at his hand.

Then at her.

“Why are you kind to me?”

The question surprised them both.

Mara considered it.

“Maybe I don't believe kindness should be earned first.”

Elias swallowed.

Outside, thunder rolled across the hills.

Mara turned toward the window.

Dark clouds had swallowed the evening sky.

Within minutes, rain struck the roof.

Then harder.

Wind bent the cottonwood branches.

Mara reached for her shawl.

Elias stood.

“You're not walking home through that.”

“I have walked through rain.”

“Not that rain.”

“I live less than a mile away.”

“A mile is enough.”

She raised an eyebrow.

“Then where am I sleeping?”

“The bed.”

“And you?”

“Chair.”

Another crack of thunder shook the cabin.

Mara looked toward the storm.

Then toward Elias.

Finally she placed the shawl down.

“Fine.”

Later, the lamps were extinguished.

Elias sat near the door with his rifle beside him.

Mara lay beneath the blanket.

Neither slept.

Rain hammered the roof.

At last her voice came through the darkness.

“You always guard the door?”

“Old habit.”

“You think danger is coming?”

Elias looked toward the black window.

“Danger is always coming.”

Silence.

Then Mara spoke again.

“My husband has been gone eight years.”

Elias turned slightly.

She stared at the ceiling.

“My family left when the railroad came. Most nights there is nobody in my house but me.”

Her voice remained steady.

But loneliness lived beneath every word.

Elias recognized it immediately.

Because he carried the same thing.

Different lives.

Same empty nights.

Mara turned toward him.

“You're tired, Elias.”

“I've slept in worse places.”

“That isn't what I meant.”

The words struck deeper than she knew.

Or perhaps she knew exactly.

Mara shifted beneath the blanket.

“Come here.”

Elias froze.

She looked directly at him.

“Not because you hired me. Not because you feel sorry for me.”

A pause.

“Because tonight I don't want either of us to be alone.”

Slowly Elias stood.

He crossed the room as though every step required more courage than facing an outlaw.

He sat at the edge of the bed.

For several seconds, neither moved.

Then Mara placed her hand over his.

That was all.

No promises.

No reckless passion.

Just two wounded people beside one another while thunder shook the world outside.

Eventually Elias lay beside her.

And for the first time in years, he slept without keeping one hand near his gun.

Morning brought light.

And a question.

Mara stood near the window.

“If last night meant something,” she said, “I will not be your secret.”

Elias's chest tightened.

She wasn't asking whether he wanted her.

She was asking whether he was brave enough to stay.

And staying frightened him more than dying ever had.

He opened his mouth.

Then hoofbeats thundered outside.

A rider stopped hard in front of the cabin.

The sheriff appeared moments later.

“Elias!”

Elias reached instinctively for his revolver.

Sheriff Caleb Morris stepped inside, breathing hard.

“We've got trouble.”

“What kind?”

The sheriff looked at Mara.

Then back at Elias.

“Wickham escaped custody.”

Every trace of warmth disappeared from Elias's face.

Mara had heard the name before.

Wickham.

The brother of an outlaw Elias had captured the previous year.

A violent man.

A patient man.

And someone who had once promised Elias that losing his brother would be repaid in blood.

Mara looked at him.

“You said danger is always coming.”

Elias checked the cylinder of his revolver.

“Yes.”

Outside, the storm clouds were gone.

But something far worse had begun moving toward them.

---

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. Advertising is off. This choice does not authorize advertising trackers.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.