Freedom and Fresh Starts

The Door Judson Left Open · Chapter 5 of 6

Chapter 5

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

By early summer, Crow Ridge transformed.

Wildflowers appeared between rocks.

The creek ran clear.

Elk moved through the high meadow in the mornings.

Josie loved the mountains now.

But Judson had been right about one thing.

She needed to understand what freedom meant before choosing where to spend it.

So she used part of the money borrowed safely against her land to rebuild O’Malley’s store.

Not as charity.

As an investment.

O’Malley resisted.

“You don't owe me.”

“I know.”

“That building burned because of trouble involving your family.”

“Still not my debt.”

“Then why?”

Josie smiled.

“Because I want to.”

Those words became precious to her.

Because I want to.

Not because Amos demanded it.

Not because hunger forced it.

Not because fear required it.

Because she chose.

O’Malley finally accepted a formal partnership.

Josie took responsibility for ordering textiles, preserved food, medicines, and household goods.

She discovered she had a talent for business.

Judson pretended not to be surprised.

“You knew?”

“You kept my pantry better organized in two weeks than I had in eight years.”

“That isn't business.”

“You also told O’Malley he was paying too much for coffee before you even knew you owned land.”

“I was right.”

“You were.”

Josie began spending several days each month in town.

Judson never asked her to stop.

That mattered.

He missed her.

That was obvious.

On the evenings she returned, he always happened to be working near the trail despite insisting it was coincidence.

One afternoon she caught him waiting.

“You've been standing here long?”

“No.”

“Judson.”

“Ten minutes.”

Caleb rode behind her carrying supply boxes.

“He’s been here nearly an hour,” he announced.

Judson glared.

Caleb laughed and rode toward the barn.

Josie smiled.

“You missed me.”

“No.”

She stepped closer.

“No?”

“Cabin was quiet.”

“That's missing me.”

“Wasn't enjoyable.”

“Also missing me.”

Judson sighed.

“Fine.”

She kissed his cheek.

“I missed you too.”

Not everything was easy.

Amos remained in town.

After recovering from his injuries, he stopped drinking.

At first Josie assumed it was temporary.

Weeks passed.

Then months.

He worked hauling lumber for the rebuilding effort.

One morning, Josie entered O’Malley’s and found Amos repairing a broken shelf.

Their eyes met.

He removed his hat.

“Morning.”

“Morning.”

He did not approach her.

Did not ask for forgiveness.

Did not tell her he had changed.

He simply returned to work.

That was new.

Later O’Malley told her Amos was living in a small bunkhouse and paying his debts.

“Every dollar.”

Josie nodded.

She did not rush toward reconciliation.

Forgiveness, she was learning, did not require forgetting boundaries.

In July, representatives from the railroad arrived.

They wanted her land.

The offer was substantial.

Very substantial.

Josie sat across from three businessmen inside the rebuilt trading post.

Judson waited outside.

One representative glanced toward the window.

“Your husband isn't joining us?”

“He isn't my husband.”

“Your adviser, then?”

“No.”

The man looked surprised.

“You're negotiating alone?”

“Yes.”

Two hours later, Josie rejected their first offer.

And their second.

She accepted the third after securing not only payment but an agreement that the railway would build a stop near town and employ local workers.

When she walked outside, Judson was leaning against the porch.

“Well?”

“I sold a strip.”

“How much?”

She whispered the number.

His eyebrows rose.

“Good God.”

“I think they underestimated me at first.”

“I imagine they won't again.”

She smiled.

“Do you know what I can do with that money?”

“Anything.”

That word struck her.

Anything.

Months earlier she could not afford a meal.

Now she could go east.

Buy a house.

Open a business.

Travel.

Start over anywhere.

Judson seemed to realize the same thing.

Over the following weeks, he became quieter.

At first Josie thought she imagined it.

Then one night she found him repairing the barn roof after dark.

“Judson.”

He looked down.

“What?”

“Come inside.”

“Almost finished.”

“You said that an hour ago.”

He finally climbed down.

During supper, he barely spoke.

Josie set down her spoon.

“What is wrong?”

“Nothing.”

“Don't insult me.”

His jaw tightened.

“Railroad money came through.”

“Yes.”

“You're free now.”

“I was free before.”

“You know what I mean.”

She waited.

Judson stared at the table.

“You can go anywhere.”

“And?”

“And you should.”

Her heart dropped.

“What?”

“See cities. Buy something that's yours. Meet people.”

“Why are you saying this?”

“Because I don't want you waking up five years from now and realizing you stayed on a mountain because I happened to be kind to you during one winter.”

Josie stared at him.

“You still believe that?”

“I don't know.”

“I told you I wanted to stay.”

“Before you had options.”

Anger rose inside her.

She stood.

“You arrogant man.”

Judson looked stunned.

“You think this is arrogance?”

“Yes.”

“I’m trying to give you freedom.”

“No. You’re trying to decide what freedom is supposed to look like for me.”

He opened his mouth.

“No.”

Josie pointed toward him.

“You have spent months telling me nobody gets to choose for me. Now you're doing exactly that.”

His face changed.

She continued.

“You think freedom means leaving because I can. What if freedom means staying because I can leave?”

Judson stared.

Josie’s voice softened.

“I know there are cities.”

He said nothing.

“I know there are other men.”

His jaw tightened.

“I know there are houses bigger than this cabin.”

She stepped closer.

“But none of them are what I want.”

“Josie.”

“No. You listen now.”

He did.

“The first night I came here, I thought you'd hurt me.”

Pain crossed his face.

“You gave me your bed.”

She touched his hand.

“I thought kindness had to hide a price.”

Her eyes filled.

“You taught me it didn't.”

“That's not enough reason to spend your life with a man.”

“No.”

Josie smiled through tears.

“It isn't.”

She moved closer.

“I love the way you talk to animals when you think nobody hears.”

Judson looked alarmed.

“You heard that?”

“I love the fact that you pretend my biscuits are ordinary even when you eat six.”

“Five.”

“Six.”

He almost smiled.

“I love that you're afraid of crying women.”

“Reasonably cautious.”

“I love that you always ask.”

His smile vanished.

“You ask before touching me. Before deciding for me. Before entering a room when I’m changing. Before using money that belongs to both of us.”

She rested her palm against his chest.

“I love that you are the strongest man I know and have never once needed me to be afraid of that strength.”

Judson’s eyes shone.

Josie whispered, “I don't love you because you rescued me.”

His breathing stopped.

“I love you because once I was safe enough to see who you really were, I chose you.”

The cabin went silent.

Judson covered her hand with his.

“You sure?”

Josie laughed through her tears.

“You are still asking?”

“Probably always will.”

“Good.”

She reached into her pocket.

Judson frowned.

Josie placed something in his hand.

It was a simple brass ring she had purchased in town.

His eyes widened.

“What is this?”

“A question.”

“Josie…”

“You said nobody should decide my future.”

“Right.”

“So I’m deciding.”

She swallowed.

“Judson Rourke, will you marry me?”

He stared at her.

For several seconds he seemed incapable of speech.

Then the feared mountain man dropped to one knee.

Josie's breath caught.

Judson held her hands.

“Only if you're certain.”

She shook her head.

“You may be the most difficult man alive.”

“Probably.”

“Yes, Judson.”

He smiled.

“Yes?”

“Yes.”

He stood and lifted her from the floor.

Josie laughed.

His kiss was deep and warm and full of everything they had refused to rush.

Outside, summer rain began falling over Crow Ridge.

Inside the cabin, a woman who had once been traded for flour made the most important choice of her life entirely for herself.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. Advertising is off. This choice does not authorize advertising trackers.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.