Freedom and Fresh Starts

The Door Judson Left Open · Chapter 4 of 6

Chapter 4

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

Spring did not arrive gently.

It attacked winter.

Snow melted from the lower slopes in torrents. Creeks swelled. Mud swallowed the trails, and sunlight returned in long golden stretches.

Josie stood outside one morning wearing the blue dress she had sewn from Judson’s wool.

Judson came from the barn and stopped.

“What?”

He stared.

Josie looked down at herself.

“Is something wrong?”

“No.”

“Then why are you staring?”

His mouth curved.

“Because I can.”

She laughed.

Their relationship had changed after the kiss.

Not quickly.

Judson remained maddeningly careful.

But the distance between them disappeared.

They shared the bed now without separate blankets.

Sometimes Josie woke with her cheek against his chest.

Sometimes Judson woke to find her hand tangled in his shirt.

Neither complained.

Still, he never assumed.

Every touch seemed to contain a question.

Josie had once believed passion meant being overwhelmed.

Judson taught her it could also mean being trusted.

One afternoon they rode down toward town.

The first trip since Amos’s visit.

Josie was nervous.

Judson noticed before they reached O’Malley’s.

“You want to turn around?”

“No.”

“You sure?”

“Yes.”

They entered together.

Conversation faltered.

Then Caleb grinned from near the stove.

“Well, look who survived the mountain monster.”

Josie smiled.

“Barely.”

Judson frowned at him.

Caleb laughed.

O’Malley approached.

“Miss Hale.”

“Mr. O’Malley.”

He looked at her blue dress.

“You look well.”

“I am.”

The surprise in several faces should have offended her.

Instead it amused her.

A woman named Margaret Ellis crossed the room.

She had known Josie’s mother.

“Josie?”

Josie smiled uncertainly.

Margaret embraced her.

“We thought…”

She stopped.

“Dead?” Josie supplied.

Margaret flushed.

“Not after Caleb came back.”

More people approached.

The stories surrounding Judson had already begun changing.

Not because he had defended himself.

Because other people finally spoke.

Caleb told everyone about his brother.

The deputy mentioned Judson’s conduct during Amos’s accusation.

O’Malley admitted what had happened at the trading post.

Truth moved more slowly than rumor.

But it moved.

Josie was examining fabric when the door opened.

Silas Mercer entered.

The room changed immediately.

He was in his forties, neatly dressed, with silver at his temples and an expensive black coat.

His eyes settled on Josie.

“So.”

Judson moved beside her.

Silas smiled.

“Relax, Rourke. I’m not here to steal your woman.”

Josie stepped forward.

“I’m not his woman.”

Judson looked at her but said nothing.

Silas smirked.

“Good to know.”

“I’m my own woman.”

His smile disappeared.

Judson’s expression became faintly proud.

Silas lowered his voice.

“Your father owes me money.”

“That’s between you and him.”

“He promised something he couldn't deliver.”

“Me.”

Silas shrugged.

“A wife.”

Josie’s stomach twisted.

“You tried to purchase a woman from her father.”

“I offered security.”

“You offered to erase gambling debts.”

Silas’s face hardened.

“Careful.”

Judson stepped forward.

Josie touched his hand.

“No.”

Then she faced Silas.

“I spent years being careful around men because everyone told me what happened when women weren't. I’m finished.”

Several people turned.

Silas looked around.

His pride had been challenged publicly.

That made him dangerous.

“You think Rourke makes you untouchable?”

“No.”

Josie smiled.

“I think I make my own decisions.”

Silas left without buying anything.

Judson watched him go.

“He's trouble.”

“I know.”

That evening they stayed at a small boardinghouse because the trail was too muddy for safe travel.

At midnight, someone pounded on their door.

Judson opened it.

Caleb stood outside.

“O’Malley’s is burning.”

They ran.

Flames climbed from the trading post roof.

People formed a bucket line.

Josie joined immediately.

Judson disappeared into the building.

“Judson!”

Smoke poured from the doorway.

Minutes passed.

Then he emerged carrying O’Malley.

Part of the roof collapsed behind them.

Josie rushed forward.

O’Malley coughed violently.

“Someone hit me.”

Judson crouched.

“What?”

“Back room. I was closing.”

Josie stared at the flames.

“This wasn't an accident.”

By dawn, most of the trading post was gone.

The deputy searched the ruins.

He found an empty lamp-oil can near the back entrance.

Silas Mercer was nowhere in town.

Neither was Amos.

Josie felt sick.

“You think my father helped him?”

Judson did not answer.

“Tell me.”

“I think Amos is desperate.”

The same word Judson had used months earlier.

Desperate men do ugly things and call them necessary.

Two days later, they found Amos.

Half-conscious beside the river.

Someone had beaten him.

Josie knelt beside him.

“Pa?”

His eyes opened.

“Josie.”

Judson checked his injuries.

“Ribs broken.”

Amos grabbed Josie’s sleeve.

“Mercer.”

“What happened?”

“He wanted the deed.”

“What deed?”

Amos coughed.

“Your mother’s land.”

Josie froze.

“My mother didn't own land.”

“Yes.”

He closed his eyes.

“She inherited eighty acres north of town.”

“Why didn't I know?”

“Because when she died…it became yours.”

Josie's blood chilled.

Judson looked at Amos.

“You couldn't sell it.”

Amos shook his head.

“Needed her signature.”

Understanding came all at once.

Silas never wanted a wife.

He wanted Josie’s land.

“Why?” she asked.

Amos swallowed.

“Railroad survey.”

Judson’s face hardened.

“The new line.”

Amos nodded.

“It may cross that acreage.”

Land near the railway could become enormously valuable.

Josie stood slowly.

“My whole life.”

Tears filled her eyes.

“You told me we had nothing.”

Amos looked ashamed.

“I borrowed against expectations.”

“You knew I owned land?”

“Yes.”

“And you starved me?”

“I thought—”

“You let me go hungry while you gambled on land that belonged to me?”

“Josie—”

She backed away.

Something inside her broke cleanly.

Not painfully this time.

Cleanly.

“Mercer offered to clear your debts if I married him because marriage would give him influence over the property.”

Amos nodded.

“I’m sorry.”

Josie laughed once.

There was no humor in it.

“Now?”

“I was wrong.”

Judson remained silent.

He understood that this moment belonged to Josie.

Her father reached toward her.

She did not take his hand.

“I hope you recover.”

Amos flinched.

“But I cannot keep sacrificing pieces of myself so you don't have to face what you've become.”

She walked toward Judson.

“Let's go.”

Amos called after her.

“Josie.”

She stopped.

He whispered, “Your mother would be ashamed of me.”

Josie closed her eyes.

“Yes.”

Then she left.

The deputy arrested Silas Mercer two days later when he tried to board a stage heading east.

Evidence connected one of his employees to the trading post fire.

Amos eventually admitted Silas had pressured him to bring Josie back.

For the first time, Amos told the entire truth.

It did not repair what he had done.

But truth rarely repairs.

Sometimes it only stops the damage from spreading.

The land deed was recovered from a lockbox.

Josie held it beneath the courthouse window and stared at her name.

Josephine Hale.

Owner.

For the first time in her life, she legally possessed something valuable.

Judson stood nearby.

“So,” he said.

“You're a wealthy woman now.”

“Potentially.”

“Railroad might make an offer.”

“What should I do?”

His eyebrows rose.

“You asking my advice?”

“Yes.”

“Keep the land until you know what you want.”

She smiled.

“You didn't say sell.”

“No.”

“You didn't say invest.”

“No.”

“You didn't tell me what decision to make.”

“Getting slow in my old age.”

Josie took his hand.

“No. You're exactly the same.”

Outside the courthouse, people passed beneath bright spring sunlight.

Josie squeezed his fingers.

“Judson?”

“Yes?”

“I know what I want.”

He looked at her.

She smiled.

“But I'm going to make you wait a little longer.”

His eyes narrowed.

“That cruel streak is new.”

“You brought it out in me.”

And for the first time, Josie walked through town beside Judson without caring who watched.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. Advertising is off. This choice does not authorize advertising trackers.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.