Freedom and Fresh Starts

The Blue Handkerchief by the Stove · Chapter 5 of 7

Chapter 5

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

Harlon had never feared dying.

He had spent too many winters alone in the mountains to pretend that death was anything but patient.

But standing beside the Bitter Creek compound, watching six rifles turn toward Cora and Elsie, he discovered something worse than fear for himself.

Fear of failing someone who trusted him.

Again.

Silas Redd smiled beneath the brim of his hat.

“Put your hands where I can see them.”

Harlon slowly raised his hands.

Cora remained kneeling beside Elsie.

The younger girl clung to her sister's coat.

Mercer stepped forward.

“Been a long ride, mountain man.”

Harlon ignored him.

He looked at Redd.

“What do you want?”

Redd spread his arms.

“What's mine.”

“Neither girl belongs to you.”

The trader laughed.

“That's a pretty sentiment.”

He removed a folded document from his coat.

“Unfortunately, I've got papers.”

Harlon stared at him.

“Papers don't make people property.”

Redd's smile thinned.

“In this territory, papers make plenty of things possible.”

He nodded toward the compound.

“Take them.”

Two guards approached.

Cora pulled Elsie behind her.

“No!”

One guard grabbed her arm.

Harlon moved.

He struck the man hard enough to send him sprawling into the mud.

The second guard raised his rifle.

A gunshot cracked.

The bullet struck the dirt beside Harlon's boot.

“Enough!” Redd shouted.

Harlon froze.

Redd held a revolver aimed toward the sisters.

“Another move, and one of them pays for it.”

Harlon slowly stepped back.

Cora stared at him.

He met her eyes.

And though he said nothing, she understood.

He was asking her to stay alive.

They locked Harlon inside an old storage shed.

Cora and Elsie were taken to the laundry house.

For the first time in three years, the sisters were together.

But they were prisoners.

Elsie sat beside Cora on a narrow cot.

She had grown taller than Cora remembered.

Her hands were rough.

There were scars across her knuckles.

But when she leaned against her sister's shoulder, she was still the little girl who had once been afraid of thunder.

“Did Pa send you?” Elsie asked.

Cora swallowed.

“No.”

“Is he dead?”

“I don't know.”

Elsie looked down.

“I used to wish he was.”

Cora wrapped an arm around her.

“You don't have to think about him anymore.”

Elsie was quiet.

Then she whispered, “Who is the big man?”

“Harlon.”

“Is he your husband?”

Cora shook her head.

“No.”

“Then why is he helping?”

Cora looked toward the locked door.

“Because he's a good man.”

Elsie considered that.

“Are there really good men?”

The question hurt.

Cora remembered asking almost the same thing in Harlon's cabin.

“Yes,” she whispered.

“There are.”

Meanwhile, Harlon studied the storage shed.

The walls were made of old pine boards.

The roof sagged.

A small window had been nailed shut.

Two guards waited outside.

He could overpower them if they came close enough.

But escaping alone would accomplish nothing.

He needed the girls.

He needed the ledgers.

And he needed witnesses.

He sat against the wall and thought of Gideon Pike.

Of Martha Bell.

Of Samuel Price.

And of the people in Bitter Creek who had spent years pretending not to see what happened behind Redd's fences.

Redd's power depended on fear.

Harlon understood fear.

He had seen it hold stronger men captive than chains ever could.

But he also knew something Redd had forgotten.

Fear could change sides.

At midnight, the shed door opened.

Mercer stepped inside carrying a lantern.

“Well,” he said, “look at you.”

Harlon remained seated.

Mercer leaned against the doorframe.

“Silas says you're worth something alive.”

“Does he?”

“Big fellow like you. Strong back. Knows the mountains.”

Harlon looked up.

“You offering me a job?”

Mercer grinned.

“I'm offering you a way to keep breathing.”

Harlon rose slowly.

Mercer's hand moved toward his revolver.

“Easy.”

Harlon stopped.

“What happens to the girls?”

Mercer shrugged.

“Redd has buyers.”

Harlon's expression did not change.

But something in his eyes made Mercer step backward.

“You should've stayed in your cabin,” Mercer muttered.

Harlon spoke quietly.

“You should've stayed out of Missouri.”

Mercer frowned.

“What?”

“You remember a little girl named Elsie?”

The man's smile returned.

“Hard to remember them all.”

Harlon took one step closer.

Mercer drew his revolver.

“Stop.”

Harlon stopped.

Then he said, “One day, somebody's going to make you remember every one.”

Mercer slammed the door.

The lock turned.

Harlon waited until the footsteps faded.

Then he smiled grimly.

Because Mercer had left the lantern inside.

And Harlon had noticed that one wall of the shed was built against a stack of dry timber.

At the boardinghouse, Martha Bell was preparing for war.

Not with rifles.

With evidence.

Samuel Price had brought the ledgers.

Gideon Pike had arrived from Clearwater with three men who had lost relatives to Redd's labor scheme.

A former deputy from another district had agreed to carry sworn statements to the territorial marshal.

And Martha had spent the evening speaking to families throughout Bitter Creek.

For years, they had been afraid.

Now they knew that someone had finally challenged Redd.

The news spread.

A mountain man had been arrested.

Two sisters had been captured.

And the records proving Redd's crimes were in the hands of people willing to testify.

By dawn, more than thirty townspeople had gathered outside Martha's boardinghouse.

Gideon looked at the crowd.

“You sure about this?”

Martha tied her bonnet beneath her chin.

“No.”

She picked up a heavy iron skillet.

“But I'm tired of being afraid.”

Inside the laundry house, Cora heard shouting.

Elsie sat upright.

“What is it?”

Cora went to the window.

Smoke rose near the storage shed.

Men were running across the compound.

Then she heard a familiar voice.

“Harlon!”

It was Gideon.

A moment later, a bell began ringing in town.

Not once.

Not twice.

Again and again.

Cora turned toward Elsie.

“Stay behind me.”

The laundry door burst open.

Mercer entered with a revolver.

“Move!”

Cora stepped in front of her sister.

“No.”

Mercer raised the gun.

“I said move.”

For a moment, Cora was back in Missouri.

Seventeen years old.

Watching a stranger drag her little sister away.

She remembered the stove poker.

The blood.

The helplessness.

But she was not seventeen anymore.

And she was not alone.

She lifted her chin.

“No.”

Mercer's expression twisted.

He reached for her.

Cora grabbed the boiling kettle from the stove and threw its contents across the floor in front of him.

Mercer stumbled backward, shouting as hot water splashed his boots.

Cora seized Elsie's hand.

“Run!”

They burst through the rear door.

Outside, chaos had overtaken the compound.

Townspeople crowded the gates.

Guards shouted.

Horses screamed.

Smoke rolled from the storage shed.

And through the confusion, Harlon appeared.

His coat was scorched.

Blood ran from a cut above his eyebrow.

But he was alive.

“Cora!”

She ran toward him with Elsie.

Then a gunshot rang out.

Harlon staggered.

Cora screamed.

He dropped to one knee.

Blood spread across his shoulder.

Behind him, Silas Redd stood with a smoking revolver.

“You should've stayed on your mountain!” Redd shouted.

Harlon struggled to rise.

Cora moved between him and the gun.

Redd aimed again.

And for one terrible second, she understood exactly what courage meant.

It was not the absence of fear.

It was choosing to stand when every part of your body begged you to run.

She looked directly at the man who had stolen three years of her sister's childhood.

“Then shoot me,” she said.

The compound fell silent.

“Because I'm not letting you take her again.”

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. Advertising is off. This choice does not authorize advertising trackers.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.