They smelled the smoke before they reached the ranch.
Not wood.
Grass.
Dry autumn grass burning fast beneath mountain wind.
Catherine rode harder.
Pain hammered her shoulder.
Grayson shouted for her to slow down.
She ignored him.
When they crested the ridge, her stomach dropped.
The south pasture had become a moving wall of orange.
Flames raced through grass almost waist high, pushed north by wind.
Toward the cattle.
Toward the remaining barn.
Toward the creek.
Men from town were already arriving with shovels, blankets, buckets, and two water wagons.
Catherine jumped from her horse.
“Move the herd!”
Ben Harper pointed.
“Already trying!”
Cattle bellowed behind the west fence, frightened by smoke.
Catherine ran toward the gate.
Grayson caught her good arm.
“No.”
“Let go.”
“Your shoulder.”
“My cattle.”
“You can’t drive two hundred frightened animals with one arm.”
“Watch me.”
He tightened his grip.
“Catherine.”
Something in his voice stopped her.
“You’ll get trampled.”
“So help me.”
He stared.
Then released her.
“All right.”
Together they opened the west gate.
Catherine mounted again.
Grayson rode beside her.
Three ranchers joined them.
They pushed into smoke.
Visibility disappeared.
Catherine could barely see her mare’s ears.
The herd surged.
A frightened steer broke left.
Catherine swung around, shouting.
Her shoulder screamed every time she pulled the reins.
But the animals knew her voice.
She had raised many of them from calves.
Slowly, the herd moved toward Miller Creek.
Behind them flames jumped the first firebreak.
Someone shouted.
The wind shifted.
Fire rushed sideways.
Grayson appeared through smoke.
“Creek! Now!”
Catherine drove the herd.
Hooves thundered.
Cattle splashed into shallow water.
Some crossed.
Others crowded along the bank.
Then Catherine heard a horse scream.
She turned.
A rider had fallen.
Ben Harper.
His horse stumbled after stepping into a badger hole.
Ben lay directly in the fire’s path.
Catherine wheeled her mare.
Grayson shouted.
She rode back.
Smoke closed around her.
For one terrifying moment she saw nothing.
Then Ben appeared, crawling.
Catherine reached him.
“Hand!”
“My leg!”
“Give me your hand!”
He grabbed her left wrist.
Catherine tried to pull him upward.
Her mare panicked.
Fire roared closer.
Then Grayson emerged.
He jumped from his horse, lifted Ben almost completely off the ground, and shoved him across Catherine’s saddle.
“Go!”
“What about you?”
“Go!”
“Grayson!”
“I have my horse!”
His horse had already bolted.
Catherine realized it immediately.
“No!”
Grayson slapped her mare’s flank.
The animal surged forward.
Catherine fought to turn.
Ben’s weight made it impossible.
She saw Grayson disappear into smoke.
“GRAYSON!”
No answer.
Catherine reached the creek.
Men pulled Ben from the saddle.
She immediately turned back.
Doc Harris grabbed her bridle.
“Don’t.”
“Let go.”
“The whole pasture is burning!”
“Grayson’s in there!”
Catherine kicked free.
Before anyone could stop her, a figure emerged through the smoke.
Walking.
Grayson.
His coat was smoldering along one sleeve.
He carried a calf across his shoulders.
Catherine laughed and sobbed simultaneously.
“You idiot!”
Grayson reached the creek and put the calf down.
“You came back.”
“So did you!”
He looked at the calf.
“Was in the fence.”
Catherine stared at him.
Of course.
The man had nearly burned alive rescuing livestock.
“You’re insane.”
“I’ve heard.”
Then Catherine noticed blood.
His sleeve was torn.
Not burned.
Cut.
“What happened?”
Grayson looked toward the smoke.
“Someone was waiting.”
Catherine went still.
“What?”
“Man with a knife.”
“Who?”
“Didn’t know him.”
“Where is he?”
“Ran.”
This had not been merely arson.
Someone had expected Catherine or Grayson to enter the smoke.
The fire suddenly looked different.
It had been bait.
Sheriff Boone arrived an hour later.
By then townspeople had dug enough firebreaks to contain the flames near the creek.
Thirty acres burned.
Two cattle died.
The barn survived.
No people were killed.
Boone examined Grayson’s arm.
“You see his face?”
“Enough.”
“Recognize him?”
“No.”
One of the ranchers nearby spoke.
“I might.”
Everyone turned.
Samuel Beckett owned property south of Pendleton’s holdings.
“What do you mean?”
“I saw a rider leaving before the fire spread. Red scarf. Gray horse.”
Boone frowned.
“Know him?”
“Name’s Luther Crane.”
Catherine had heard it.
One of Pendleton’s enforcers.
“Where does he stay?”
Beckett looked toward the southern hills.
“Old mining camp near Willow Gap.”
Boone immediately organized men.
Catherine stepped forward.
“I’m coming.”
“No.”
She stared at the sheriff.
Boone raised both hands.
“You’ve had enough.”
“He burned my land.”
“And that’s why you’re staying where I can find you alive.”
“I’m not a child.”
“No. You’re a witness in three separate criminal cases who keeps riding toward gunfire.”
Catherine opened her mouth.
Grayson said, “He’s right.”
She turned slowly.
“Excuse me?”
Grayson clearly reconsidered his life choices.
“About this one thing.”
“Careful.”
Boone almost smiled.
“Stay here.”
The posse rode out.
Catherine spent the next several hours helping clean burns from cattle, repairing damaged fence, and pretending she was not worried.
Mostly about the ranch.
Partly about the investigation.
Entirely about Grayson.
He sat near the creek while Doc Harris stitched his arm.
Catherine brought coffee.
“You always get cut when helping me?”
“Not always.”
“We’ve known each other four days.”
“Fair.”
She sat beside him.
They watched smoke drift above the black pasture.
Catherine whispered, “I almost lost everything twice.”
Grayson looked toward her.
“Not everything.”
“My home.”
“Yes.”
“Pasture.”
“Grass grows.”
“My brothers.”
“They made their choice.”
Catherine stared into her coffee.
“I keep wondering when they made it.”
“What?”
“The choice.”
She swallowed.
“Were they always like this? Did I just not see it?”
Grayson considered.
“People don’t become one thing all at once.”
“So they could’ve changed.”
“Still can.”
Catherine looked at him sharply.
“You think I should forgive them?”
“I didn’t say that.”
“What are you saying?”
“Their choices belong to them.”
He nodded toward her bruises.
“What you do with what they did belongs to you.”
Catherine remained quiet.
“Forgiveness isn’t letting someone hurt you again,” he said.
“That from experience?”
“Yes.”
“Who’d you forgive?”
“Myself.”
She looked at him.
He did not explain.
He did not have to.
Catherine understood enough.
The posse returned after sunset.
They had Luther Crane.
Alive.
And they had found something else.
A wagon loaded with kerosene.
Two rifles.
Pendleton Land Company payroll slips.
And a letter.
Boone handed it to Catherine while standing beneath a lantern.
The letter was signed only with initials.
L.C.—Finish the Miller matter before Bell sends word east. No property, no water, no witnesses.
S.P.
Catherine read it twice.
“Is that enough?”
Boone nodded slowly.
“With the other letters? Yes.”
“To prove Pendleton ordered it?”
“To charge him for conspiracy.”
Catherine released a breath.
But Boone looked troubled.
“What?”
“The letter is dated yesterday.”
“So?”
“Pendleton was already under scrutiny.”
“He panicked.”
“Maybe.”
“What else?”
Boone lowered his voice.
“Crane says Pendleton told him there was another plan if this failed.”
Catherine felt cold.
“What plan?”
“He won’t say.”
“Can you make him?”
“No.”
Grayson came beside them.
“Who would know?”
Catherine answered before Boone.
“Caleb.”
Everyone looked at her.
She knew her brother.
Caleb had been quieter than Jedodiah because he had known more from the beginning.
She rode back to town that evening.
The sheriff opened the jail.
Caleb sat on his cot.
His injured shoulder was strapped.
He looked exhausted.
Catherine stood outside the bars.
“We need to talk.”
“Do we?”
“Yes.”
He looked away.
“Crane burned the south pasture.”
No reaction.
“He tried to kill Grayson.”
That got one.
Small.
But Catherine saw it.
“You knew.”
Caleb remained silent.
“What’s Pendleton’s second plan?”
“I don’t know.”
“You’re lying.”
“Prove it.”
Catherine gripped the bars.
“Caleb, look at me.”
He didn’t.
“Look at me!”
Finally he did.
Catherine felt tears rising but refused to let them fall.
“Why?”
His expression hardened.
“You got everything.”
“What?”
“Everything.”
“The ranch?”
“Father.”
She stared.
Caleb laughed without humor.
“He loved you.”
“He loved all of us.”
“No.”
“Yes.”
“No, Catherine. He respected you.”
She almost recoiled.
Caleb continued.
“You stayed. You worked. You did everything right. Every time Jed and I came home, there you were. Catherine fixed the roof. Catherine balanced the books. Catherine sat with Mother. Catherine saved the calves.”
His voice broke.
“Do you know what it’s like coming home and knowing your sister became the son your father wished he’d had?”
Catherine stared.
“That’s what you thought?”
“That’s what I knew.”
“No.”
Caleb laughed.
“You weren’t there when he looked at us.”
“I was always there.”
“Exactly.”
The word landed between them.
Catherine suddenly understood.
Jealousy had rewritten Caleb’s memory.
Every sacrifice she made had become proof that he had been rejected.
Every mistake he made became someone else’s fault.
“You could’ve stayed,” she whispered.
Caleb looked away.
“No.”
“Yes.”
“Wouldn’t have mattered.”
“You never tried.”
He slammed his fist against the wall.
“I wasn’t you!”
Catherine flinched.
Caleb breathed hard.
“No,” she said quietly. “You weren’t.”
He looked back.
“And I never asked you to be.”
Something in his face cracked.
Catherine continued.
“Father didn’t leave me the ranch because I was better than you. He left it because I was there.”
Caleb lowered his eyes.
“You could’ve been.”
Silence.
After a long time he whispered, “Pendleton plans to take the will.”
“What?”
“Your father’s will.”
“Why?”
“If it disappears, he can challenge ownership through us.”
Catherine’s stomach dropped.
“Where is it?”
“Boone’s safe.”
Caleb shook his head.
“He knows that.”
Catherine turned.
At that exact moment, a gunshot sounded downstairs.
Sheriff Boone shouted.
Then glass broke.
Grayson grabbed Catherine and pulled her aside as a man appeared at the jail entrance.
Not Pendleton.
Deputy Mercer.
He had escaped his cell.
Blood ran from Boone’s forehead behind him.
Mercer held a revolver.
“Safe combination!” he shouted.
Catherine froze.
Mercer aimed at Boone.
“Now!”
Caleb stood behind his bars.
“You idiot,” he whispered.
Mercer fired.
Grayson pulled Boone down.
The bullet struck the wall.
Then Caleb did something Catherine never expected.
He reached through the bars and grabbed Mercer’s coat.
Mercer spun.
Caleb held on with his good arm.
“RUN!”
Catherine moved.
Grayson tackled Mercer.
The revolver discharged.
Mercer screamed.
Boone regained his feet and struck him with the butt of his gun.
Mercer collapsed.
Silence.
Catherine turned toward Caleb.
He was sitting on the floor of his cell.
His wound had reopened.
Blood soaked the bandage around his shoulder.
“You…”
Caleb laughed weakly.
“Don’t make too much of it.”
Catherine approached.
“Why?”
He looked at her.
For once, no bitterness remained.
“I already helped burn one home.”
He leaned his head against the bars.
“Wasn’t helping them steal what was left.”
Catherine swallowed.
It did not erase anything.
It did not heal her shoulder.
It did not rebuild the cabin.
It did not undo the terror.
But it was a choice.
A different one.
And Catherine remembered what Grayson had said.
People did not become one thing all at once.
Neither did they become better all at once.
Sheriff Boone retrieved the will from the safe.
Then he made a decision.
“We’re moving Pendleton.”
“Where?” Catherine asked.
“Fort Benton if I can arrange federal custody.”
“Why?”
“Because his money reaches too many people here.”
Boone looked toward the cells.
“And I’m done finding out which ones.”
The next morning, Pendleton was placed in a guarded wagon.
Crane.
Mercer.
Sloan.
Caleb.
Jedodiah.
All would face hearings.
Catherine stood on the street as the wagon prepared to leave.
Jedodiah looked toward her.
“I don’t expect you to forgive me.”
Catherine said nothing.
“I just wanted you to know.”
She nodded once.
Caleb did not speak.
He simply looked at her.
Catherine looked back.
Then the wagon rolled away.
Grayson stood beside her.
“How do you feel?”
Catherine watched her brothers disappear down the road.
“Like somebody cut half my family out of me.”
Grayson nodded.
“And the other half?”
She looked toward the distant mountains.
“Still standing.”
That afternoon they returned to Miller Valley.
A dozen wagons followed.
Timber.
Nails.
Windows.
Shingles.
Food.
Tools.
Half of Miller’s Crossing had decided Catherine would not spend winter without a home.
She stared at the wagons.
“I can’t pay for all this.”
Mrs. Larkin climbed down from one.
“Good.”
“What?”
“Because nobody sent a bill.”
Catherine tried to argue.
Nobody listened.
Grayson handed her a hammer.
“One-handed?”
“I thought you hated being told you couldn’t.”
Catherine smiled.
“I’m learning to hate you.”
“No, you aren’t.”
Her smile disappeared.
Because he was right.
And both of them knew it.
---